Baby Girl versus Adoptive Couple Essay - 1552 Words

There was a court case, Baby Girl v. Adoptive Couple, in which a child who was partially Cherokee Indian, because of her father, and Hispanic, because of her mother. The adoption of Baby Girl was a difficult one due to the fact that she has an ancestry of Cherokee Indian. Therefore, under the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), the adoption of Baby Girl seemed impossible because Biological Father had the right to have custody of his child, Baby Girl, if he chose to. So, the court greatly sees that by giving Baby Girl back to Biological Father would be in the child’s best interest under the ICWA, because there is the assumption that if she is with her Biological Father and her culture, she will not suffer any type of emotional distress. For†¦show more content†¦Therefore, from a very young age, Baby Girl might have questioned why she did not share the same physical features as her parents; thus, causing her to have a failed ethnic identity. In a 1987 study, conducted by S imon and Alstein, an Indian adopted child stated, â€Å"It bothers me that I’m Indian. People don’t look up to Indians. The whites always fought the Indians and the Indians got beat. We aren’t looked up to. There is nothing special about being Indian† (Sindelar, 2004). This clearly indicates that the native adoptee feels inferior to his White adoptive parents; therefore, the child was obviously unable to fully integrate into the White culture without feeling inferior. In the case of Baby Girl v. Adoptive Couple, she may have been at risk to feeling the same inferiority due to the extreme exposure of the White culture and the lack of exposure and pride towards her own ethnicity; therefore, causing possibilities of distress and discomfort in her own skin. Sindelar suggests that there is a phenomenon known as the Split-Feather Syndrome, in which â€Å"social, psychological, and emotional disabilities — among expatriated Indian people, i.e., those who were placed and raised in non-Indian homes† (2004). The Split-Feather Syndrome may be due to the extremities in culture difference between Indian and other cultures. For instance, the ideologies of child-rearing, family bonding,Show MoreRelatedAdoption Of The American Dream1622 Words   |  7 Pagesfamilies, adoptive families are created through the law. Even if a child is raised by an adult throughout their whole life, they won’t be recognized as their own until they are adopted. Adoption didn’t come around until the mid-nineteenth century. You have to go through a state court and have good reasons why the child should be adopted by you. Once a child is adopted and it is finalized by the court in the final hearing, the birth parent has no rights over the child. The new adoptive parents haveRead MoreThe Gift Of Adoption By Dr. Jane Aronson1586 Words   |  7 PagesAdoption, an extensive process, allows individuals who have been given up or taken away from thei r biological parent(s) the opportunity to be welcomed into the loving and warm embrace of adoptive parent(s). Adopting a child is a such a unique experience and it takes a person with a lot of heart and courage to do so. Carried in Our Hearts: THE GIFT OF ADOPTION: Inspiring Stories of Families Created Across Continents written by Dr. Jane Aronson is a beautiful tribute to the process of adoption. Read MoreThe Many Benefits of Adoption2071 Words   |  9 Pageswoman who cannot have children of their own, a newborn baby, and a single mother who will certainly be unable to provide for the infant due to her young age, lack of financial support, or another variety of unfortunate circumstances. Making the decision to adopt a child is without a doubt one of the best options available for couples who are unable to conceive, but by thinking of adoption as nothing more than the fallback option for childless couples, adopting a child doesn’t even come to mind for theRead MoreA Study Of Intactness Of Adoptive Families And Behavioral Problems Of Older Children4176 Words   |  17 Pages The Older Adopted Child: A Study of Intactness of Adoptive Families and Behavioral Problems of Older Children Sarah A. Kell University of California Riverside â€Æ' Abstract The older adopted child is a unique case of adoption where the child is of school age. The definition of what constitutes a case of older child adoption has changed numerous times over 20th century, but school age is currently the definition for an older child. This means children as early as five years old are considered difficultRead MoreEssay on Same Sex Couples Adoption Rights2243 Words   |  9 PagesShould Same Sex Couples Have the Same Adoption Rights as Heterosexual Couples? Krystal Davis COM/220 March 13, 2012 Barbara Plyler Should Same Sex Couples Have the Same Adoption Rights as Heterosexual Couples? In 2008, President Barack Obama stated there are too many children who need loving parents to deny one group of people adoption rights (eQuality, 2005). A child will benefit from a healthy, loving home, whether the parents are gay or not (eQuality, 2005). With thatRead MoreThe Movie Juno Is Not Only Cute And Quirky1698 Words   |  7 Pagesher the baby has finger nails (Malkovich et al., 2007). Although this is bothersome to Juno she continues into the clinic but once inside she feels alienated by the bureaucracy of the clinic, and ultimately decides not to go through with the abortion(Malkovich et al., 2007). After leaving the clinic Juno talks to her friend Leah who helps Juno decide to give her baby up for adoption (Malkovich et al., 2007). Juno immediately begins searching ads and finds a suitable home for her baby. She thenRead MoreGay Adoptions- Pros and Cons/Ethical Views1851 Words   |  8 Pagessame-sex marriage but Homosexual couples married in those states are still facing obstacles when it comes to becoming parents through adoption. Some states allow it, some states ban it. Not only are they fighting their way to be viewed as an equal marriage with the same rights a Heterosexual couple have, but many claim they should also have the right to adopt thus giving adopted children a secure emotional and stable home making such adoptions ethical. Adoptions by gay couples is ethical because they haveRead MoreI Had Pity For Both Morgan And Kiki During This Period1421 Words   |  6 Pagescan blame yourself...for doing exactly what I begged you not to do!...I knew you were a liar.. .I knew you were a pathetic, petty little girl who would break my son s heart...hell, we all failed Morgan didn t we?! Get out! Kiki was left to bawl in Sonny s arms, and I was howling laughing on the floor. I never understood why Carly didn t hate Kiki, when the girl had a hand in permanently tarnishing Michael and Morgan s relationship. She had more contempt for Sabrina! Carly and Alexis tag-teamedRead MoreLife of a Teenager7946 Words   |  32 Pagesadulthood† (Ernisch). Families should stay intact or their teenagers will develop many problems,   Love relationships affect teenagers because some become less interested in their education and more with their boyfriend or girlfriend. Most teenage girls have reported about being abused by their boyfriend. As shown in an article, â€Å"They note that over 25 percent of adolescents are victims of dating violence or aggression, and that dating violence precedes martial violence in up to 50 percent of cases†(asRead MoreTaking a Look at Adolescent Pregnancy2571 Words   |  10 Pages Adolescent pregnancy is defined as pregnancy in girls age nineteen or younger. There are different risk factors for adolescent pregnancy. Besides being young, some of them include: poor school performance and not graduating college, or in most cases high school, lower socio economic status and not being able to take care of themselves let alone another person, and older male partners who do not usually want to be involved in their child’s life, which ends up leaving parents to raise their ch ildren